image Irish Republicans have never had the same fixation with catching the zeitgeist that afflicts some of the far left. In fact you have to be impressed with the resolutely untrendy use of language in phrases like “the Free State Administration” and "Martin McGuinness is a British Crown minister… his job is to administer the Queen of England’s writ in Ireland”. Cruel but true.

So what are we to make of the Real IRA’s announcement that it is rebranding itself as the armed wing of the anti-capitalist movement? There is some truth in their analysis of the big picture.

“Most people can see the picture: the bankers grease the politicians’ palms, the politicians bail out the bankers with public funds, the bankers pay themselves fat bonuses and loan the money back to the public with interest. It’s essentially a crime spree that benefits a social elite at the expense of many millions of victims."

It’s their conclusion that shows a severe inability to learn from the previous decades of their movement’s history.

"We have a track record of attacking high-profile economic targets and financial institutions such as the City of London. The role of bankers and the institutions they serve in financing Britain’s colonial and capitalist system has not gone unnoticed.”

They also have a track record of shooting men delivering pizzas and abandoning bombs outside primary schools but that sort of thing doesn’t have the same cachet as declaring all out war on British capitalism.

The whole interview is as barmy as it is opportunist. They are probably telling the truth when they say that they are turning recruits away but even the much more proficient and better resourced IRA bombings in England at Canary Wharf and Bishopsgate can’t be said to have done much damage to finance capital.

What gets left out of most Republican accounts of their armed struggle is the complete dead end it represented. Many of those who served long prison sentences are now suffering from alcoholism and other effects of post traumatic stress disorder. The utter futility of their campaign is obvious to all but that handful who deceive themselves that having Martin Mc Guinness in a supporting role to Peter Robinson’s organ grinder represents any sort of victory.

Fifty quid says that they will keep their promise and launch some sort of attack in England within twelve months. It may even be against a financial institution. Equally certain is that a lot of young militants who refuse to learn the lessons of Republicanism’s failure will spend many wasted years in jail repeating every mistake that Adams and Mc Guinness made before them. Wrapping it up in a bit of anti-capitalist rhetoric does not make it any sort of new political thinking or an attempt to engage with the working class in Britain or Ireland. It’s dead end adventurism.

13 responses to “Anti-capitalism for numpties”

  1. Mark Victorystooge Avatar
    Mark Victorystooge

    At a time when the left is weak, other forces are stealing a march on it. In some places, far right forces are claiming to stand for working class concerns. If Irish Republicans are playing up militant anti-capitalism, it suggests there is a hole in the set-up the left is failing to plug, so they’ll move in, or try to. Instead of the patronising dismissal, a better approach might have been to ask why the left has vacated such ground.

    As to long-term Republicans succumbing to alcoholism and stress, I really don’t think this is a plus point for the left. First of all, there are heavy drinkers on the left, and frustrations and setbacks have probably taken a psychological toll as well. People I knew who had been through the WRP, for example, seemed to be psychiatric walking wounded at the very least. Also, the British left has no great record of success to set against the presumed failure of Irish Republicanism. In 20 years, lots of left papers have been sold and demos organised, yet most of not all groups are actually smaller in membership and influence than they were.

    Like

  2. Great article!

    What this group do highlight is a need to attack the rich, to target the attacks on them – in ‘peaceful’ ways of course. Lets make it as unpleasant for these bastards as they are for the rest of us.

    Like

  3. The sad reality of control.As long as our comfort comes from capitol, and politicians cushions of warm retoric,we will be diging holes,and that is not tackling the religion and all that we are part of.

    Like

  4. Real IRA = PIRA – Social Democracy = militaristic nationalism + populism?

    Like

  5. Socialism,without arrogance.Our humanities time.

    Like

  6. It’s reminiscent of the Greek “anarchists”, who conveniently started petrol bombing banks just as the unions there organised mass action against the cuts.
    The British Unions do the same thing and, lo and behold, the “Real IRA” announce a campaign against bankers in Britain!

    It’s about as convincing as a bad script from “Spooks”.
    Maybe the scriptwriters are ghosting until the next series?

    Like

  7. Mac Uaid neglects to mention that this “statement” is obtained by Graniad journalist, Henry MacDonald, someone who has a history in Irish Politics.

    Like

  8. so he’d know that if he goes round telling porkies that there might be serious consequences. It rings true.

    Like

  9. Harry Steelestown Avatar
    Harry Steelestown

    Equally certain is that a lot of young militants who refuse to learn the lessons of Republicanism’s failure will spend many wasted years in jail repeating every mistake that Adams and Mc Guinness made before them. Wrapping it up in a bit of anti-capitalist rhetoric does not make it any sort of new political thinking or an attempt to engage with the working class in Britain or Ireland. It’s dead end adventurism.

    Sound analysis Liam, and also sounds a lot like statements that OSF/WP have been making for the last 40 years! (a compliment BTW).
    RIRA’s problem is that this is not 1969-72, the objectives conditions of that time are no more and trying to get a “campaign” going by appealing to a few hundred alienated youths in Belfast and Derry is futile and quite frankly nuts!

    Like

  10. Carl Dinnen’s report on Channel 4 used the very cruel device of letting some RSF members speak directly to the camera. They managed the near impossible job of making Sinn Fein’s Elisha McLaughlin sound smarter than Gramsci by comparison.

    The most sophisticated of them said “we’ve been doing this since 1798 and we’re gonna keep on doing it.” Another didn’t much beyond “the peelers hate Taigs”. Both these things may have a kernel of truth but they don’t represent much in the way of breakthrough strategic thinking.

    Like

  11. Yes Liam you appear to have a Sticks analysis. Nevertheless Republicanism eclipses all the non Republican left in its various guises if we look at the development of all the antiGFA organisations. Of course as simpletons we will bow to your superior track record and await your instructions on how to complete the tasks of the Irish revolution.

    Like

  12. Mark Victorystooge Avatar
    Mark Victorystooge

    I am sure all kinds of forces read posts like “anti-capitalism for numpties” and are reassured by the British left’s lack of, and contempt for, anything that is even vaguely paramilitary.
    So are the EDL. According to reports, they turned over the UAF again, this time in Tyneside.

    Like

Leave a comment

Trending