Someone is going to be in big trouble after this demonstration. On a superficial level it was well organised and coordinated. The speakers turned up. Trafalgar Square was booked. The police had been told. But someone had forgotten to say their prayers asking their god for good weather. It was the wettest day in London in a couple of months. A very negligent bit of god-bothering.

This was a very important demonstration. Ostensibly it was organised by the unions and what are now called “faith groups”. There was not too much evidence of the unions having put in the work.

The demand was for a “pathway to legal status for long term migrants”. As you can see from the photos it was comprised almost entirely of immigrant workers and church groups. The organised left was, for all practical purposes, absent and there were not many Labour Movement banners either. One end of the Tower Hamlets UNISON banner was carried by a vicar. What you had in abundance was groups of workers who had been organised through churches. The march was led by Cormac Murphy O’Connor and the Catholic church was there in force. It was bewildering to watch the affection with which he was greeted.

When I arrived at Westminster Cathedral I couldn’t help noticing that lots of people were carrying Union Jacks. This rekindled a reflex developed in a north Belfast childhood. But I don’t smoke and didn’t have any matches on me. I think the point was that by ostentatiously displaying the butcher’s apron the marchers were demonstrating their enthusiasm to be British.

This is the sort of event that should have been organised and built either by the radical left or the unions.
It speaks badly of the condition of working class organisations in Britain that the churches have much deeper roots and a much more developed organising capacity than they do. But you could see the positive side of religion in action on the day. Their religious communities are giving some of the most exploited workers in Britain a sense of belonging, militancy and power. As they strode enthusiastically out of the cathedral and cheered as they entered Trafalgar Square I saw just how impotent and out of touch the British left is sometimes.

Next year socialists need to be there in force. Here was a group of workers with a sense of solidarity and, I thought, a willingness to fight.

4 responses to “Strangers into citizens demo – contradictory in a bad way”

  1. Thanks for the report, Liam. I am personally sorry to have missed this demo but have been unwell most of the day. The BBC online news featured quite a lengthy account and the London regional news led with a report of the march: http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk/6631193.stmWhat was striking watching the television footage was the virtual absence of the far left and, indeed, the unions. From what Adrian of Permanent Revolution told me, only the recently formed UNITE (merged T&G and Amicus) and UNISON had any visible presence on a march of several thousand. Looking at the BBC report only two labour movement figures – Jon Cruddas, one of the many candidates to be deputy leader of New Labour – and veteran T&G bureaucrat, Jack Dromey, were listed among the rally speakers.John McDonnell sent a message of support and indicated that he was already committed to speak in Burnley today. On his campaign blog, McDonnell makes telling points about the extremely limited character of the proposed “amnesty” and pledges to table an amendment in Parliament to extend the right to “regularisation”: http://www.john4leader.org.uk/2007/05/strangers-into-citizens-demonstration.htmlCheers, George.

    Like

  2. Liam Mac Uaid Avatar
    Liam Mac Uaid

    George, recovering from Saturday’s drinking on Monday does not make you “unwell”. I was surprised by how favourable and extensive the TV coverage was.

    Like

  3. Liam – And I thought this was now the friendly blog: I had long since recovered from Saturday night’s alcoholic overindulgence!In my previous post I had forgotten to mention that the demo’s organisers had apparently encouraged marchers to carry Union Jacks on the march – perhaps this was inspired by the sight of so many Latino and other migrant workers in the States carrying the Stars & Stripes on the massive demos witnessed last year. Or perhaps it was still another misguided attempt to ‘reclaim’ the Union flag from the fascist right.George.

    Like

  4. I agree with Liam (and George) that this is an important movement and it is indeed essential that the union movement and the revolutionary left start to mobilise in far greater numbers for the cause of ‘amnesty’ or the right to stay for all workers 9though as a note of caution apparently some of the organisers were arguing for partial amnesties (as Liam comments)- however, I’m many of the participants would be happy for this to be extgended.In Manchester we had a far smaller though lively enough demonstration of around 250- on which there was a left and union presence. but certainly it is one fo the greatest challenges the left currently faces to overcome the division in the working class between settled legal workers and the undocumented.JasonBolton NUT

    Like

Leave a reply to George B Cancel reply

Trending