My brother in law’s fight for Irish freedom gave him an opportunity to develop a conlonprofessional relationship with members of the Prison Officers’ Association in the Category A wings of a number of British jails from Belmarsh to Durham. His experience, and it’s supported by a number of sources, is that they don’t always succeed in bringing a spirit of impartial detachment to their work. Read Gerry Conlon’s autobiography if you are unconvinced.

As groups of organised workers go they do have to be among the most loathsome. But by golly they know how to pull off a one day strike and make it solid. According to the interviews on TV local officials started receiving phone calls from 5am saying that they all had to walk out at 6am. There had been no preliminary indicative votes or any of the other hogwash other unions are so fond of. On the strength of a phone call from a regional official and the instruction from their branch leadership 90% or more of POA members struck. Maybe the RMT could do that but no other respectable union in Britain could.

Their pay review body recommended a rise of 2.5% this year. The government decided that should be staged, with an initial 1.5% rise followed by another 1% six months later. This reduces it to a below inflation 1.9%. This is similar to the same sort of rubbish deals that New Labour is imposing on public sector workers. By and large the POA has been a force for evil in British prisons but it is tightly organised. That is one of the reasons Labour has been so keen to privatise the jails.

Of course they are workers in uniform but let’s assume they decide to flout the law and declare illegal industrial action. Would you want to stand in the street collecting money for them. Cops in Special Branch probably have grievances too but who could lift a finger to support them?

Below is a description of what is happening in the Trotskyist led PCS written by a SR supporter in that union. How is it that the POA has shown itself to be one thousand times bolder and what sort of reflection is that on British unions today?

The PCS national leadership is currently organising hundreds of meetings of PCS members to discuss a separate PCS national pay/staffing campaign that has died a death since a national strike on Mayday. However this seems to be just a means of appearing as if they are doing something – there is little attempt to lead the members by the Socialist party leadership of PCS. 

Let’s keep our fingers crossed that more unions decide to show the same sort of gumption as the screws but you won’t find me outside Tesco’s with a collecting bucket for them.

7 responses to “Prisoner Officers – anyone fancy setting up a support group?”

  1. Louisefeminista Avatar
    Louisefeminista

    “Of course they are workers in uniform “….

    On the one hand yes, but on the other they are still agents of the state. You can’t divorce their function from their social nature. They have an anomalous class position.
    I know that the POA has cleared up its act as there has been inquiries into the state of the Special Hospitals regime and the grip the POA did have on these institutions (Blom Cooper and Fallon reports 1992 and 1997). Blom Cooper esp. exposed the connections some POA members had with the far right and the appalling levels of sexism, racism and homophobia that existed in these hell holes.

    And on a personal level when I visited women in Broadmoor you would get some real off-hand and out of order comments about the residents. There was this lack of awareness and understanding and “can’t care less attitude”.. Sometimes downright hostile and confrontational.

    In some respect, I agree with Liam that I have a problem showing my support because of what they do and their sole function. And yes, as I said the POA has cleared up its act and changed politcially. But they do make me feel very uneasy.

    Like

  2. “workers in uniform”? well, so are police then!
    no.one fancies setting up a support group – least of all the screws or their leadership, who weren’t/
    aren’t in favour of any generalised breach of the pay limit, they just want a pay rise for themselves.
    what would be the basis of a support group? perhaps, workers’ control of jails: workers to agree emergency cover for those vulnerable residents/inmates inside…?
    fk the screws!

    Like

  3. Good post, Liam.

    It may be a bit more complex thsan workers in uniform but I’m sure it’s more complex than they’re just agents of the state – screw’em!

    A little debate here

    http://www.permanentrevolution.net/?view=entry&entry=1619
    And an interesting and I’d say excellent article here

    http://www.permanentrevolution.net/?view=entry&entry=1624

    Like

  4. Having spoken to a couple of SR comrades over the weekend who have regular contact with the criminal justice system I think that my reaction to the POA was a bit of a kneejerk.
    One comrade, who has contact with prison officers every week, suggested that we should view their union in much the same way we’d view the CWU. The stereotype ex army BNP screw is a fast dying breed and is being replaced by numbers of black and women officers. Some of the union’s leaders supported John Mc Donnell and the union has made many progressive demands.

    Like

  5. Sure- it’s always good to re-examine stereotypes and is pretty healthy.

    Not sure if we can treat it purely as the CWU though

    would we be for raising money in the union movement for solidarity for prison officers’ strike?

    I wouldn’t completely rule it out but I think there would be a very important debate and part of a struggle to win the POA to progressive positions on prison reform/ crime/ etc.

    But certainly agree it’s not as simple as they’re a bunch of cops

    think they also play a role in the rmt inititiated rank and file network

    Like

  6. a discussion on this was at the PR website that you have a link to. a response from Mark H to those that have a problem with the POA: “but life throws up contradictions and while weird purists who pass themselves off as leftists can only wail and denounce the POA revolutionaries have to take an active approach that uses the contradiction to hasten the break up of the capitalist order.”
    I’m unsure who or what he is on about here, but they do get quite nasty with correspondents who don’t agree with them (unless it is one of their comrades, in which case they might ‘take it on board’)

    Like

  7. It’s not aimed at anyone in particular- it’s aimed at the tendency in many of us to have a bit of a kneejerk reaction.

    I think it’s good we try to be a bit more open-minded and responsive to life’s contradictions.

    Nothing nasty there

    Like

Leave a reply to Jason Cancel reply

Trending