Here’s something about Che I wrote for Socialist Resistance a couple of years ago. The photo was taken in the Museum of the Revolution in Havana. You can see what they are trying to do.

Cuba 07 102Che Guevara, almost uniquely among 20th century revolutionary leaders, is still a symbol of rebellion for the youth of the 21st century. Being as photogenic as Johnny Depp is always a help. But it’s the facts of his life and his very humanistic approach to socialism that guarantee his place in the history of future revolutions.

Ernesto Guevara Lynch de la Serna as he was known to his parents was born in Argentina in 1928. He went to Buenos Aires University to study medicine where he abstained from politics. In 1949 he went motorcycling in northern Argentina and a couple of years later he travelled to Chile, Colombia and Peru. Having come from a comfortably off family this trips were his first real experience of the poverty of the farmers and Indians.

His travels took him to Guatemala which had a left-leaning government led by Jacobo Arbenz. Guevara was there when the CIA organised a coup which overthrew this government because it was giving some land to the peasantry. By this time Guevara considered himself a Marxist and, according to some accounts, he tried to organise armed resistance to the coup.

With the defeat of the Arbenz government in 1954 Guevara went to Mexico City. That’s where he met Fidel and Raul Castro . They had fled Cuba and were organising a small guerrilla army to return and overthrow a corrupt, pro-American government. The Cubans were being given a professional military training by Alberto Bayo, a veteran of the Spanish civil war.

In November 1956 Guevara sailed to Cuba with Castro’s 80 strong “army” on a boat called the Granma. They didn’t have much luck. They were noticed immediately and the group had to split up. Guevara was wounded in an ambush. Although he was the group’s doctor it was at this point that Guevara decided to abandon his medical supplies and save the ammunition the guerrillas needed.

In January the rebels successfully attacked the barracks at La Plata. By the spring of that year their military campaign has intensified and they are building support among the peasant farmers. On New Year’s day 1959 the dictator Batista fled to Miami and the revolutionaries found themselves in government.Cuba 07 088

Guevara finds himself transformed from guerrilla leader to the Director of the National Bank and the Minister for Industries. And this was when he showed himself to be at his most revolutionary. Most people who make that sort of transformation quickly find it hard to see beyond their day-to-day job. They are relieved that they are no longer sleeping in mountain forests hunted by a dictator’s army. Guevara was made of different stuff. His slogan was: “The duty of a revolutionary is to make revolutions.”

He was convinced that the Cuban revolution could only survive if there were successful revolutions in other parts of the world. For him the victory of the Vietnamese against the Americans would be a victory for the Cuban revolution. He wanted to open up new revolutionary wars and was convinced that what had worked in Cuba could succeed in other countries. In 1965 he took 100 veterans of the Cuban revolution to Congo to support Laurent Kabila. This brief episode failed. What worked in Cuba didn’t work in Africa.

Still convinced that he could support the Vietnamese by opening up a revolutionary war in Latin America Guevara travelled to Bolivia in 1966. He had a guerrilla force of 29 Bolivians, 16 Cubans and 3 Peruvians but didn’t have the support of the Communist Party or the strong Bolivian miners’ union. The result was predictable. Guevara was taken prisoner and murdered in September 1967.

The French philosopher Jean-Paul Sartre called Guevara “the most complete man of his time”. He was a doctor, an economist, a banker, a revolutionary, a military theoretician and an innovative Marxist thinker. Guevara died trying to come to the aid of the Vietnamese revolution, half a planet away from Cuba. This at a time when the Vietnamese revolution was creating a new revolutionary generation in Europe and America. Guevara was the shining revolutionary star. The opposite of the old men who represented Soviet Stalinism he was the uncompromising revolutionary idealist who refused to make rotten deals with the old world.

We will leave the last word to our comrade Che Guevara: “It was precisely love for humanity which conceived Marxism…the desire to combat misery, injustice and all the exploitations suffered by the working class which made Marxism arise from the mind of Karl Marx.”

Technorati Tags: , , , ,


Del.icio.us : , , , ,
Ice Rocket :

22 responses to “Che Guevara”

  1. Has anyone bought a Guevara t-shirt outside Cuba? Is it just a t-shirt saying I’ve been to Cuba? I fear lots of people wear the t-shirt without much knowledge of Guevara.
    Yet Che is a much more interesting figure than just a guerilla leader ie he started to think through some of the problems with Cuban socialism and democratic questions. Also he showed sympathy for some Cuban trotskyists by helping getting them out of prison.

    Like

  2. It’s striking the way in which Che’s image is used in Cuba. On one hand people try to sell you the coin that bears his image and every shop is full of Che memorabilia.

    On the other hand you feel that it’s used as an icon to drive away the evil spirits of corruption and counter-revolution. He still seems to represent the purity and idealism of what Cubans understand to be the purpose of their revolution.

    Like

  3. I must say I am an ignorant American, but i’m learning! I have seen Che’s image on t-shirts and posters, but did really know his story at all. I know now from reading your article the fascinating and “complete man” he was. I really enjoyed your article and I’m going to the library this week to find books about him.

    Like

  4. Saintamyjane I’m glad you liked the piece. It was written as a very brief introduction to one of the outstanding figures of the 20th century.
    It’s not just in the US where are lot of people are unfamiliar with Che. But bear in mind that taking to the mountains with 70 or 80 people is not always the most effective way to change the world. That’s why I wouldn’t always rely on Che as a guide to what to do, more as a symbol of incorruptible integrity and idealism.

    Like

  5. I’d recommend Carlos Tablada’s book on Che to anyone who is interested in his economic theories which always get very neglected in my view but are actually a good attempt to deal with what happens after the revolution. Here’s the info:

    Che Guevara: Economics and Politics in the Transition to Socialism

    Pathfinder Press, Pub. 1998

    Like

  6. Thanks for highlighting that book tami,

    I will certaiinly buy it, sounds very interesting.

    Like

  7. It is quite an interesting book.

    There’s no doubt in my mind that Che was a genuine revolutionary and fighter for freedom and that is why he has become such a symbol throughout Latin America and other parts of the world.

    Of course not everyone wearing a Che T-shirt understands the political significance but for many I think it is a badge of standing for the workers, for revolution, for freedom against imperialism.

    There are I thinmk still massive problems with Che’s politics- mainly the ansence of workers’ democracy, the emphasis on centralised bureacracy, the underestimating of the essential task of making links between rural armies and the urban organised industrial working class.

    Che’s ideas about emulation and the new man in the Tablada book are interesting but without a full blooded workers’ democratic revolution with the economy based on the democratic councils of workers, peasants and soldiers it cannot really be said that Che was in any sense a Trotskyis or even becoming one.

    Quite clearly though he wasn’t a counter-revolutionary and his message of hope, struggle and determination continues and long may it to inspire.

    Like

  8. I’ve no idea what it means but Che and the LCR have been all over French TV tonight.
    First Michel Lowy was on the news channel LCI defending Che against a counter revolutionary scumbag called Jacob Machover. See the link below. It’s in French but scumbags talk the same bollocks in any language.
    Then Besancenot’s book about Che produced in collaboration with Lowy was plugged on the 7pm light entertainment show. That sort of thing doesn’t happen here.

    http://programmes.france2.fr/dans-quelle-etagere/index-fr.php?page=accueil&id_article=15

    Like

  9. The Tablada book is interesting. It always amazes me how much Guevara accomplshed in his short life.

    I reckon that had he been around today, he would have been able to bridge the gap between Marxism and the rather amorphous “socialism in the 21st century” — the Marxist emphasis on central economic co-ordination and the 21st century emphasis on decentralisation and workplace democracy.

    Like

  10. On the workers democracy theme: there was a very good programme about Bolivia under Evo Morales last night in the BBC4 “Why Democracy” series, called “Looking for the Revolution”
    It showed very clearly that any so-called workers representative who tries to sell out in Bolivia will feel the heat from the mass assemblies of workers and unemployed (which were overwhelmingly composed of indigenous women) The level of political awareness and rank and file participation were just astonishing.
    Even though Guevara remains an iconic figure in Bolivia, I think this level of political understanding cannot be unrelated to the long-term activities of the Trotskyist organisations in the workers movement in Bolivia.
    It shows rather clearly that any “top-down” movement which doesn’t allow for re-election of workers representatives is a total non-starter there.
    I can’t believe this doesn’t apply to much of the rest of Latin America.
    Well worth seeing if it’s repeated

    Like

  11. I wonder if it will become available on DVD?

    John Pilger’s documentary “The War on Democracy” is also worth seeing, and he makes the same point that the grassroots of the movement is very vibrant, and they have been betrayed before and won’t be so easily fooled again.

    Like

  12. Is that program with Lowy and Machover on YouTube as well? I can’t use Windows Media player.

    I think thousands of people wear the tee-shirt with no earthly idea of who Che was, but growing up in the American socialist left, his biography was a bedtime story for me (I mean literally… told by my father, along with Bernadette Devlin’s and, for some reason, Tony Benn’s… which led to me thinking that Tony Benn must be considerably younger and hipper than he in fact is). The bookstore associated with the Young Socialist Alliance in Madison in the late 1960s was the Che Guevara Movement Bookstore, which was more than a little counter to prevailing American SWP tenets.

    Anyway, the jarring bit of costumery with Che’s iconic image I’ve seen lately is Abhishek Bachchan’s wearing a red Che tee-shirt in one of his dance numbers, in _Jhoom Barabar Jhoom_, filmed in London. What did you think of the film of the book _The Motorcycle Diaries_? I thought the prose of the book was execrable, much though I venerate Che. Politically, I mean.

    Like

  13. I swear this happened:

    One man says to a youth in a Che t-shirt, “Just think, who’d wear a tshirt with a picture of Gordon Brown?”

    “Huh?” says the youth.

    You know, Che Guevara…” And he relates the “economist? I thought you said communist!” story.

    The youth looks puzzled. “Who is this you’re talking about?”

    Like

  14. Watching the DVD about the life of Ernest Mandel recently reminded me that Che read Mandel’s Marxist Economic Theory, quite significant when Cuba was developing relations with the USSR, which had denounced Mandel as a counter-revolutionary. I have a copy in Spanish of Che’s Critical Notes on the Soviet Manual of Political Economy which contains sometimes v caustic remarks on the Manual’s formulations. On this, see Lowy: http://www.internationalviewpoint.org/spip.php?article1218&var_recherche=Lowy%20Che

    On Che and Trotsky, Lowy says:
    Trotsky is absent from these notes [the ones I mentioned], but we find an interesting reference to him in the debates at the Ministry of Industry: you cannot destroy opinions with blows from a club, that would be the death of any free development of intelligence. “It is obvious that we can learn a series of things from Trotsky’s thinking”, even though his subsequent activity was a mistake. Guevara ironically adds that the Soviets accused him of Trotskyism, putting this label on him like a “San Benito” – that is the clothing in which the Spanish inquisition dressed heretics when it led them to the stake…

    Like

  15. Returning to T-shirts – I’ve just found someone on ebay selling ‘Sooty in che guevara style t-shirt’.

    Like

  16. D.J.P. O'Kane Avatar
    D.J.P. O’Kane

    I saw a guy on campus lately wearing a t-shirt with Che’s face, blindfolded, and the caption ‘che commodita’, which I think is Italian for ‘here is the commodity’.

    Like

  17. che..
    thank you hero ………..

    Like

  18. my iternal idol along with MARX,TROTSKY,FIDEL,SUKARNO,TAN MALAKA and noedays AHMADNINEJAD…..!!!

    Like

  19. […] 03/12/2009 Raad Yousif أضف تعليق Go to comments Che Guevara by […]

    Like

  20. A lot of modern day anticapitalists idealize Che Guevara. The book written about him by the leaders of the NPA in France was in my opinion of a religious nature.

    His mistakes may have been understandable, but that is not really the point. For example, he was one of the leaders of a governement allied with Russia while Russia was proclaiming to the world that in order to build socialism it needed nuclear weapons capable of killing hundreds of thousands of workers at a time. Che could not have stopped them doing this, but was he even opposed ? What terrible demoralization for anticapitalists everywhere to be told that the way forward was by preparing horrific massacres.

    One more example, the famous moment when Che “disappeared” from the leadership of Cuba. What could be more demoralizing for workers, more anti-marxist in the deepest sense than to take this kind of decision without carefully explaining in detail and discussing with the most radical sections of the working class?

    Che represented, for all his merits, socialism “from above”.

    Like

  21. Incidentally, in the South West of France, where I lived until last week (!) the main bookstore in the town centre is selling “back to school” sets (satchel, pencil case, ringbinder etc) with Guevara’s image on. It’s in the window as a major presentation, so it must sell.

    Like

  22. Mark Victorystooge Avatar
    Mark Victorystooge

    Che Guevara is a symbol of resistance – it goes without saying that a “left” that does not resist has to attack and undermine him.

    Like

Leave a reply to Andrew Cancel reply

Trending