Commemorationitis  is a dreadful political disease. The commemoration can never be as exciting as the original event. That was the problem confronting the organisers of Sunday’s festival in Victoria Park. For starters in 1978 the area was the heartland of British fascism. Thirty years on the fascists are now living in Essex, London’s periphery and the de-industrialised towns of the north. Staging the event on the intersection of two boroughs with big non white populations and a minuscule fascist presence was not the obvious way to confront an enemy now living in Dagenham and Romford. At the original event the bands were not household names but were on the cutting edge of youth culture and had reputations for radical politics. No such claim has ever been made for Hard Fi.

Musically the standout moment was Poly Styrene revisiting Oh bondage up yours. Second best was The View’s Same Jeans. I’m not convinced anyone got the bronze medal. Damon Albarn’s The Good, The Bad and The Queen were martyred by the worst sound system I’ve heard in thirty years of listening to live music. To get a taste of how bad it was try listening to Radio Thailand on a cheap short wave radio. Jimmy Pursey merits a special mention. He tried to murder White Riot in 1978. Rent the Rude Boy video for confirmation. After thirty years’ practice he succeeded. You can see the video evidence soon.

This might sound like a grumpy complaint but there was an inordinate amount of swearing from the stage. I’ve no desire to shake hands with a fascist but 80% of the stage speakers insisted that we all fuc# one.

On the plus side the weather was not as dreadful as had been predicted and some tens of thousands of mostly young people came out and identified themselves with an assertively anti-racist music festival. That made it worth doing.

 

 

21 responses to “Love Music Hate Racism carnival”

  1. You do sound like a grumpy bastard Liam 😉

    Like

  2. Bit harsh about Hard-Fi, imho. The first album had its smattering of politics, and if you think Sham 69 were “. . . on the cutting edge of youth culture and had reputations for radical politics . . . “, then I’ve got some magic beans I would like to sell you. 😉

    Like

  3. Good point about Sham 69. The piece was written a bit hastily but the chums I was with, all of whom were frolicking in the highest of spirits, had the same opinion of the performances as me.

    Like

  4. I am a bit dubious about the assessment of the reputaions of the headline bands in 1978.

    Strangely the line up for the 1978 carnival was very similar to the headline acts for Reading in 1978, if I remember correctly.

    Like

  5. Thanks, Liam, this is really useful. I was trying to explain the concept of ‘begrudgery’ to someone the other week, and I couldn’t think of a good example.

    Like

  6. It wasn't like this back in the day... Avatar
    It wasn’t like this back in the day…

    Macuaid, there was me thinking that a Beirut-loving wannabe hipster would be down with the kids but alas no.

    Like

  7. Yes, Liam, 60.000-100.000 people on an anti-racist event is so boring and uninspiring. A real waste, really. And not in any way as uplifting as being on a bus with Galloway.

    Like

  8. Norwegian is far too downbeat, at least Liam said it was worth doing.

    Like

  9. The headline acts for Reading 78 were the Jam, Status Quo and Patti Smith, apparantly. I was there but don’t remember the Jam. None of them played the RAR carnival. However Tom Robinson was at Reading but played two places before that day’s headliners. And we can’t forget Jimmy Pursey – Sham 69 were at Reading and he sang with the Clash at the RAR carnival.

    So I’d say you remember it even less than I do

    Like

  10. Geoff

    I bow to your superior memory.

    Like

  11. The fact is that a lot of the performances I heard were uninspiring and you judge a music festival by the music. If anyone who was there from 2.30 till 5.30 can tell me about a gem of a set that I missed then I’m willing to stand corrected.

    Like

  12. I wasn’t at either event so can’t comment on the music though I certainly agee about Hard-Fi (subjective tho’ such opinions inevitably are)

    However, 60 000 people at an antiracist gig is no mean feat and probably deserves celebrating in itself and perhaps shows there is a constituency for militant antifascist street politics and leaves me with a feeling of hope.

    Indeed my experience of working with young people is that most are pretty much antiracist and could be up for a spot of militant demonstration. A few afternoons of Black and white youth as well as workers occupying the council chambers to protest council cuts, privatisation and other crap services would do wonders to bring about change- fights that unite and show who are real class enemy is.

    Perhaps if we build a mass social movement to fight for our rights we might as a side effect get some really brilliant music to go with it (unless there is some really brilliant political music out there that I’m just too far from the cutting edge to know about! Though I do know some great current Ethiopian music- it’s all in Amharic though)

    Like

  13. of course ‘are’ should be ‘our’ in the above contribution (‘are class enemy’) showing either how appalling my grammar is or perhaps I am cutting edge in linguisitic matters at least

    Like

  14. Just on mattersmusical and political the fairly great- Teddy Afro has been arrested in what he and his supporters claim are trumped up charges

    The Ethiopian government had banned one of his songs that became the banner of the democracy movement during the stolen elections of 2006-
    not sure if any on here know how we might be able to raise his case in Britain

    Like

  15. for some reason can’t seem to post any links on this
    so paste into tool bar

    http://www.news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/africa/7362885.stm

    Like

  16. news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/africa/7362885.stm

    Like

  17. Seems to me the Sunday event to have been held far too late to register the unregistered London youth vote, or to involve them in any significant pre-election antifa activity.
    Just comparing 78 and 08 events as music fests is rather banal and pointless.

    Like

  18. Yes but is it not possible ti use music to mobilise the youth in a Balck and white united fight against fascism and racism connected to a struggle for a sustainable world run for the needs of ordinary people not the destructive profits of capitalism?

    I think it is. Also can someone put me in touch with the organisers re Teddy Afro?

    Like

  19. COMMENT DELETED. Noel – if you’d like, or know how to re-submit that without the abuse please feel free or post elsewhere. Taking a dim view of ropey performances and poor sound quality does not fall within my definition of sectarian. LIAM

    Like

  20. liam
    100,000 attended anti fascist carnival.. good.
    ABUSE DELETED – LIAM

    Like

  21. well it is good- but how are we going to build on that?

    still no news on how to ge tin touch with the organisers

    I happen to think a bit of abuse is good now and again- hearing Public Enemy shout F… George Bush F… Tony Blair a few years ago may have not got us far but you know you need to get out that agresssion now and again!

    Perhaps a militant demo would be even better- could think of a few PE songs to go with that too

    Like

Leave a reply to chjh Cancel reply

Trending