You go a whole lifetime without seeing a Canadian musician and in 2008 you disregard whole continents in a bizarre flurry of Canadaphilia – Stars, Holy Fuck, Neil Young and Leonard Cohen all in a few months. What will 2009 have to offer? Hot new and old bands from  Estonia? Top sounds from New Zealand?

lc Mine was probably the traditional path to Cohen’s music. As a young man I determined to prove to myself that there was a sensitive streak inside me which women might find appealing and that my musical tastes were becoming catholic and discerning. The plan was a dismal failure on both counts but it was worth a go. Perhaps some of you were luckier.

No longer in the first flush of youth Cohen has been obliged to come out of retirement because his accountant ran off with his pension. He has been playing a series of well received shows and expectations were high in a music venue sponsored by a mobile phone company. O tempora o mores.

The glowing reviews were not wrong. The O2 is an enormous space. Cohen managed to make the evening very intimate and there were some genuinely funny, self-deprecating moments for example “the last time I played London was fourteen or fifteen years ago. I was just a sixty year old kid with a lot of crazy dreams.” It was long set – starting at just after 8pm and lasting till 11pm with a brief interval but Cohen never waned and reminded this reviewer of a more agile and dapper Albert Steptoe dressed for a date in the Dog and Duck in his trilby and smart suit.

Several times Cohen described himself as feeling “honoured” and “privileged” to be playing. He was utterly sincere. The large screens on which the show was projected revealed a profound and real modest joy at the reception his songs received. He was generous with the applause naming each musician several times in the course of the evening after they played their solo parts.

The choice of songs drew heavily from Cohen’s 1980s repertoire. The recorded versions have rather dated but songs like Tonight we take Berlin  and set closer Closing Time worked well live. The arrangements were plusher than would normally be to my taste but the musical director probably reckoned that they had to be fairly smooth to counterbalance Cohen’s golden voice. It’s easy to carp. I wanted to hear Famous blue raincoat but it didn’t make the cut. Everything else the audience wanted was in there and Hallelujah got one of the most heartfelt audience responses I’ve ever seen. Did you know that it was once voted the best ever Canadian song?

At the risk of getting too gushy – this was a superb, charming, uplifting performance and I fear that every musician I ever see again will be measured against it.

23 responses to “Leonard Cohen at the O2”

  1. Nice to find a music review of a co-religionist..

    Like

  2. A co-religionist? Now I’m intrigued! Zoroastrian, perhaps???

    My first ever live gig was Leonard Cohen in Manchester. The review the next day said that he’d sung off-key all evening but the audience didn’t seem to notice. What the hell, I enjoyed it! Amazing that he’s still going…

    Chz, Jay
    http://brizblog.wordpress.com/

    Like

  3. andyinswindon Avatar
    andyinswindon

    Isn’t there a srisk buying a tciker for the O2, that they may mishear you and give you a ticket for U2?

    Like

  4. “Cohen’s golden voice…”
    Yes he was indeed blessed with that gift…LOL!
    Just as well he’s always had excellent female backing singers. My faves are Julie Christiansen and Perla Batalla.

    To me, he’s a lyric poet, operating in the field of popular music.
    the best there is.

    “religion”
    Frequent Christian references due to Montreal upbringing.
    But despite spending several years as an assistant to Zen Bhuddist Monk, during which time he was ripped off, he’s still a Jew.

    Politics:
    Contradictory.
    “Progressive” with CP folkie influences in youth.
    One of the few people to have travelled to Cuba to sit out the missile crisis, as well as perform to Israeli troops in 1967.

    Like

  5. Prianikoff is correct despite spending time as a Buddhist monk, Cohen declared that he remained faithful to his Judaism.

    I believe it was in 1973, during the Yom Kippur War that LC played for the troops, having . His position towards Zionism seems far more ambiguous than that of the great Bob Dylan, who apparently had an argument with the Black Panther leadership over their support for Palestine and during his flirtation with evangelical christianity produced the politcally dire, “Neighbourhood Bully” that appears to be an apologia for the 1982 invasion of Lebanon.

    Leonard Cohen was at one time linked with a left wing Zionist group that supported a Bi-national solution. As witnessed in his poem “Questions for Shomrin”. He writes:

    “This poem, first publsihed in the early 1970’s, is,
    tragically, still pertainent today. It was also sent
    anonymously to a number of rabbis, selected at random,
    in New York City and posted on traffic lights,
    lampposts, and other places. The word “Shomrim” refers
    to members of the left-wing, Zionist youth organizaion
    Hshomer Hatzair that supported a binational state in
    Palestine/Israel when I was close to them.

    QUESTIONS FOR SHOMRIM

    And will my people build a new Dachau
    And call it love,
    Security,
    Jewish culture
    For dark-eyed children
    Burning in the stars
    Will all our songs screech
    Like the maddened eagles of the night
    Until Yiddish, Arabic, Hebrew, and Vietnamese
    Are a thin thread of blood clawing up the side of
    Unspeaking steel chambers

    I know you, Chaverim
    The lost young summer nights of our childhood
    We spent on street corners looking for life
    In our scanty drops of Marx and Borochov.
    You taught me the Italian Symphony
    And the New World
    And gave a skit about blowing up Arab children.
    You taught me many songs
    But none so sad
    As napalm falling slowly in the dark
    You were our singing heroes in ’48
    Do you dare ask yourselves what you are now
    We, you and I, were lovers once
    As only wild nights of wrestling in golden snow
    Can make one love
    We hiked by moonlight
    And you asked me to lead the Internationale
    And now my son must die
    For he’s an Arab
    And my mother, too, for she’s a Jew
    And you and I
    Can only cry and wonder
    Must Jewish people
    Build our Dachaus, too?”

    Like

  6. Hey Jay,

    apparently Leonard’s surprised you are still going, too…

    R.

    Like

  7. Adamski:
    Yes it was in fact, 1973, not ’67. It’s said that Cohen actually tried to enlist in the Israeli Army during the Yom Kippur War, but ended up entertaining troops. Apparently the sight of wounded soldiers and Egyptian POW’s changed his views on the nature of the conflict.

    When he was in Cuba, the Castro government weren’t sure what he was up to and there was some suspicion he was spying, or perhaps a petit bourgois pain in the arse bystander in the line of fire.

    This is the mess poets get into when they harbour fantasies of being military officers!

    I must say that despite Dylan’s reputation, I haven’t really liked him since he fell off his motorbike. Cohen has never shrouded himself in mystery, always explains his lyrics (except touchy personal issues) and is totally honest. He takes ages getting his lyrics right and in spoken interviews, there’s never a single word wasted.

    Like

  8. A. B Yehoshua’s ‘The Lover’ is a good novel that says a lot about Israel after the ’73 war, I think it’s depiction of Israeli Arabs also gives an insight into Israeli society too.

    Like

  9. Yes, great concert.

    But have to seriously politically disagree with Liam on the venue – O2 is complete crap. Only intimacy I managed was with a pair of hire-powered binoculars! Surely Liam wasn’t in the £250 seats?

    Better to head for his concerts in the Albert Hall mid November, big as it is.

    Like

  10. I once had a girlfriend who hated the music of Leonard Cohen, she said he was a misogynist, I said, “What!?! He loves women . . .”

    Like

  11. Incredibly jealous. He hasn’t toured in a decade and a half. I live only miles from the Canadian border– a straight shot to Toronto and he ain’t coming here. Count yourself as lucky. BTW what is it with Bono pushing his nose in and ruining documentaries on rock stars I like (Cohen, Strummer). He made “I’m Your Man” unwatchable.

    Like

  12. No Stuart. My seat had an oxygen mask and required crampons to access.

    Like

  13. Mark Radcliffe played “He thats no way to say goodbye” this afternoon on Radio 2 and raved about last nights show. Mentioned something about him coming back in October. Also playing the Big Chill festival.

    Like

  14. I listened to Cohen’s concert for free from my apartment when he recently played in Kilmainham in Dublin. It was lashing rain, which was unfortunate for the punters because it was an outdoors gig. My housemates paid exorbitant amounts of money to attend while I sat on my balcony drinking cans of economy lager. It was boring. I spent most of the time picking fluff from my navel.

    I’m really looking forward to Ministry playing tomorrow, apparently playing their last ever gig. Now a discussion on their politics would be interesting – http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TXIVoKrn9uQ

    Like

  15. As far as “lyrical poets, operating in the field of popular music” are concerned, D.C. Berman of the Silver Jews is in my view one of the best around. You can’t really go wrong with Silver Jews records but “American Water” is probably the best place to start.

    Like

  16. I bought the last album directly after hearing San Francisco BC. It’s very funny.

    Like

  17. Thanks for the review Liam. I want to go to his gig in November so let me know when you are booking tickets!

    Like

  18. I think the attribution of that “Shomrim” poem is very dubious.
    What autobiography?
    (Check out the forum section on the LeonardCohenfiles.com, May 2006)

    I have listened to David Berman before, but I tend to think he’s more of a ‘quirkmeister’ than a lyric poet.
    Seems to be scratching around at 30,000 Youtube hits, whereas Lennie’s ‘Hallelujah’ hits around 3.75 million and Jeff Buckley’s is not far behind.

    We need to be thinking of artists who are reaching the 1 million mark to speak of genuine popular appeal.
    So, I s’pose that means the left should try to recruit Avril Lavigne, Rihanna and crazy little poets like Soulja Boy.

    Then, if Google actually paid peformance rights to artists, the subs problem would be solved for good!

    Like

  19. Music and the economic crisis intersect once again. Spooky!


    “CHANCELLOR Alistair Darling warned yesterday there would be no more cash for public services – and revealed he was going to cheer himself up by seeing gloomy singer Leonard Cohen.
    Darling said hard times would be with us for “some time” or as Cohen put it in a song: “I’ve seen the future, brother, it is murder.”
    Making his gloomiest assessment ever of the British economy, he insisted he would not make taxpayers foot the bill for more public services spending.
    And he revealed that he had told his Cabinet colleagues bluntly they were getting no more cash for schools and the NHS.
    Darling is faced with a record deficit for the Treasury.”

    By Mark Aitken, Political Editor
    Glasgow Sunday Mail, July 20th 2008


    Hello Darling

    Like

  20. Prianikoff said: “I have listened to David Berman before, but I tend to think he’s more of a ‘quirkmeister’ than a lyric poet.
    Seems to be scratching around at 30,000 Youtube hits, whereas Lennie’s ‘Hallelujah’ hits around 3.75 million and Jeff Buckley’s is not far behind.”

    Well yes, but Hallelujah is dreadful schmaltzy crap. That sentimental songs can shift records has never been in doubt.

    Like

  21. Do you play or sing at all, Mark? I defy anyone who does to listen to the first verse of “Hallelujah” and not be moved. It goes like this… It goes on too long after that, I grant you – and Cohen’s own recordings are both pretty awful. John Cale does it justice, though. Rufus Wainwright and Jeff Buckley both give it a pretty good going-over, but when you get down to it they’re not old enough for the song; Cale is.

    Like

  22. Mark P: “dreadful schmaltzy crap”

    Couldn’t agree less. Are you sure you’re listening to the same lyrics?

    Phil: “Cohen’s own recordings are both pretty awful”

    No one’s saying Cohen can SING. But I prefer his versions of his songs to any of the covers.

    Despite being rather a reactionary , I think Brian Appleyard wrote a very perceptive review of “Hallelujah”, where he proves it’s exactly the opposite of schmaltz:-

    “Cohen doesn’t write songs like that. What he most commonly does is pour highly concentrated acid into very sweet and lyrical containers.
    Never in his entire career has he done this as well as he did in the second version of Hallelujah. ”

    See:-
    http://www.leonardcohenfiles.com/appleyard.html

    Like

  23. I already knew that Mark P had bad politics, now he confirms he has bad taste in music!

    What I particularly like in Hallelujah are all the rich biblical allusions that give the text a mythical resonance.

    The references to the story of David who wrote all the songs and psalms. The story of David is an incredible and moving story full of pathos and shadows. The child-superstar who takes on Goliath, the relationship between mad King Saul who is his friend and then enemy, and whom he eventually replaces. The bond of friendship between David and Jonathan. The story of Bathsheba is at the centre of the song. King David sees Bathsheba bathing naked on the roof of the palace and is consumed with lust, he engineers to have her husband sent to the most dangerous part of the front where he is killed, so he can marry her himself.

    The climax of the story is when he is morally indicted by the prophet Nathan who visits him and tells him a story:

    “Judge this case for me! In a certain town there were two men, one rich, the other poor.
    The rich man had flocks and herds in great numbers.
    But the poor man had nothing at all except one little ewe lamb that he had bought. He nourished her, and she grew up with him and his children. She shared the little food he had and drank from his cup and slept in his bosom. She was like a daughter to him.
    Now, the rich man received a visitor, but he would not take from his own flocks and herds to prepare a meal for the wayfarer who had come to him. Instead he took the poor man’s ewe lamb and made a meal of it for his visitor.”
    David grew very angry with that man and said to Nathan: “As the Lord lives, the man who has done this merits death!
    He shall restore the ewe lamb fourfold because he has done this and has had no pity.”
    Then Nathan said to David: “You are the man!” The story is a metaphor for David’s deeds and he has condemned himself.

    The guilt is poured into a psalm /blues(51) that begins “Lord have mercy” in the traditional styles
    and ends: The sacrifices of God are a broken spirit: a broken and a contrite heart”

    And references to Samson and Delilah – “tied you to her kitchen chair / broke your throne, cut your hair”

    Like

Leave a reply to Darren C Cancel reply

Trending