Today’s demonstration in London organised by the British Tamils Forum & Tamil Youth Organisation (UK) was distressing, infuriating and powerful in roughly equal measure. My guess is that thereP1000657 were about 3-4000 people in Hyde Park for the end of march rally. Maybe just over a couple of dozen of these were non-Tamil. It was overwhelmingly an event of the British Tamil community. This was a great strength but also a major weakness.

The context is that the Tamil national movement has suffered an utterly catastrophic defeat. It’s leadership, the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam (LTTE) தமிழீழ விடுதலைப் புலிகள் offered much to criticise. It combined a bourgeois nationalist programme with a disastrous military strategy of trying to hold onto territory while terrorising its own people. For all practical purposes this organisation has been obliterated. Its political and military cadre fell in battle or were summarily executed on capture by the Sri Lankan army. The civilian population and the LTTE rank and file are being held in camps under conditions which guarantee large numbers of fatalities. It needed a heart of stone not to feel deeply saddened watching the relatives of the detainees march though London’s streets.

As if to emphasise their impotence lots of them were carrying the flag of the United Nations forlornly hoping that the most powerless institution on the planet would offer them some comfort. Many others were carrying Union Jacks, in the sort of numbers that gives me twitchy flashbacks to a north Belfast childhood. The plea here was obvious. As people living in Britain they wanted the British government to act. Some of the slogans were calling on Gordon Brown to do something. It should be clear by now that the United Nations, Britain and the other imperialist powers are giving Ratnasiri Wickremanayake carte blanche to strangle the Tamil national movement.

The virtually complete absence of the organised left was scandalous. The largest single group was from Green Left. If you judge the matter in percentage terms the pitiful turnout from Socialist Resistance put everyone else to shame while a couple of other organisations were doing their traditional “would you like to sign this petition / buy a paper / join us routine”. It was enough to make any reasonable person incandescent.

I have never seen a community so utterly politically isolated. There were no peace groups, churches, trade unions, or any of the political and civil society spectrum that will be at next week’s STWC demo or took to the streets for Gaza. Due to the late start I was only able to stay for a couple of the speeches. Ed Davey the Lib Dem MP for Kingston and Surbiton said he was disappointed by something or other and got a round of applause for telling the audience that Simon Hughes would be asking questions in the House of Commons next week. It’s good that Hughes is doing this but a community that feels this is worth applauding is aware of its own weakness. Davey then suggested that the British government take a tougher line with the Sri Lankan regime and mentioned sanctions. This sounded promising but he only meant travel bans to the EU for members of the government and that sort of Mickey Mouse stuff. Next up was a Tory at which point it was time to go.

The Tamil community has repeatedly shown that it has tremendous organising capacity. This event was very efficiently stewarded, well resourced and had some imaginative touches. It was able to draw on some limited support from the non-Tamil political figues. However if the diaspora is to have a real impact on events back home it has to start reassessing some of the things that it’s doing – or not doing. There were some leaflets calling for a boycott of garments from Sri Lanka. This is good and could be extended to include tourism and tea, two high profile Sri Lankan commodities. Those dozens of young stewards could begin organising little pickets and stalls outside supermarkets and travel agencies. Most importantly a campaign which learns from the likes of the Palestine Solidarity Campaign how to put down real roots in unions, communities and progressive organisations is essential to prevent this year’s defeat becoming the Tamil Nakba.

An article on the Right of self – determination of Ilankai Tamils by Vickramabahu Karunarathne can be found here.

P1000666

P1000662 

P1000656 

P1000667

 

13 responses to “Tamil demonstration in London”

  1. I am sorry to have missed this.

    its a bit worrying that on the same day as the climate swoop, virtually the only bit of the British left that turned out was from ecosocialists in GL and SR.

    Ditto the Minga on tuesday, the only people from the left were some HOV people and ecosocialists.

    Hey may be the SWP, labour left, pr and the rest were all on the climate camp….i suspect not though.

    Like

  2. Indeed the absnece of the organised left is scandalous, though unfortunately hardly surprising.

    I would have thought at least some of PR were on the climate camp, Derek and can’t really explain why no one was on this apart from we are pitifully small (probably about the same as SR but in a small group lots of factors intervene busy lives etc.) but yes we should certainly cover this.

    Presumably there’s a Tamil left and a Sri Lankan left- did they come out?

    Also what about trade union presence- probably also very small?

    I think the idea of a Tamil Solidarity Campaign in th eunions along the lines of PSC is good. How can we kickstart it?

    Like

  3. despite my political differences with pr, I think that given your modest numbers there is not too much shame in this….but there are still plenty of others in larger organisations on the left who according to Liam have not put in an appearance.

    Tamil and other East Asian solidarity needs to become as important as political work involving Latin America….Farid the new Green Party international guy is working quite hard in this area.

    Like

  4. Mark without wishing to disparage the effort of those involved in Tamil Solidarity the model is utterly wrong. It takes about 2 seconds to work out that it is a 100% party front organisation and these things are the curse of the British left. I, for one, have seen enough of that nonsense.

    The task at the moment is to build a wide and broad movement in solidarity with Tamils which looks for support in the unions, progressive political organisations and radical youth. That’s what was absent from today’s demo.

    Like

  5. good point Liam….even the BBC are saying 1,000 people at climate camp http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/england/nottinghamshire/8312074.stm

    which is obviously the ecosocialist event of the weekend

    Like

  6. Liam;

    Tamil Solidarity is only a one party organisation if others on the left decide that they don’t want to be involved in it.

    The Socialist Party took the initiative in launching it – that’s not exactly a surprise given that the main hard left organisation in Sri Lanka is their sister group. They are attempting to do exactly what you propose – to build a solidarity organisation with support in the unions and amongst radical youth. There is nothing stopping you from getting involved if you so choose to.

    Like

  7. Mark Victorystooge Avatar
    Mark Victorystooge

    I was there, with a couple of friends. The only British left group I could see was the SWP, who had a stall. Considering their relative size, even their presence was token.

    Like

  8. I’ve had a quick look at the website suggested by Mark P and its demands look supportable and it is a start.

    However, it is quite clearly lniked to the Socialist Party advertising Socialist Students etc. and this probably does make it look like a front organisation. My suggestion would be that Liam contacts a couple of people on the left in London including a PR member and some others and approach TS to make it broader etc. and following from that have a concerted campaign to get union affiliation and the word out

    Like

  9. The key issue with Tamil Solidarity is that its platform is aimed against the British Tamil Forum. It’s an unfortunate bad habit that the SP run its as front (although the SP guy I bought their paper from told me that the AWL take part). However, the idea that one can build anything significant or effective against the BTF is crazy.

    For the BTP, the key task is to place pressure on the Sri Lankan government. Tamil Solidarity focuses on criticizing the British government for its crimes. To build a serious united front, the left needs to identify the issues on which large numbers of organisations and activists can unite. The basis of Tamil Solidarity, as a propaganda project aimed at exposing labour, falls far short of the possibility to link up the labour movement and the Tamil diaspora.

    Like

  10. Mark by that logic the Spartacist League is quite entitled to say that the only reason capitalism hasn’t been overthrown is because not enough people have joined it.

    Like

  11. Liam:

    When it comes to any campaign, somebody has to take an initiative. What happens after that is up to both the people that took the initiative and other people. Deciding without contacting a campaign that it isn’t for you, isn’t interested in your ideas or interested in broadening its support has something of the self fulfilling prophecy about it.

    Like

  12. it may also be a problem, that some British leftists do think, that the Mahinda regime in Sri Lanka is “leftwing”: http://www.europe-solidaire.org/spip.php?article15025

    Like

Leave a comment

Trending