Here’s a snippet from the Guardian that should give some cause to concern for a few readers of this site.

“Among those who would be considered extreme under those plans are those who advocate a caliphate, a pan-Islamic state encompassing many countries; those promoting Sharia law; and those who believe in jihad, or armed resistance, anywhere in the world.

This would include armed resistance by Palestinians against the Israeli military and those who fail to condemn the killing of British soldiers in Iraq or Afghanistan.”

It’s from a collection of articles looking at New Labour’s “grass up a Muslim” strategy which they’ve rebranded as “preventing violent extremism.”

To be honest it’s got me a bit worried. To the suspicious eye château Mac Uaid is a bit of an archive of violent extremism. In the living room there’s a carved Celtic cross dedicated to Ireland’s patriot dead made by a relative who had a lot of time on his hands in Long Kesh a while ago. Looking through the DVDs there’s Michael Collins starring Liam Neeson in which a lot of violent extremists kill British soldiers and Julia Roberts massacres an Irish accent. A few discs along is The Wind That Shakes the Barley which features a lot of violent extremists failing to condemn the deaths of British soldiers. Then there’s that DVD my sister lent me which I haven’t watched yet about the history of the junior violent extremists in the Fianna.

The cd collection is worse. Michael Mac Liammoir’s album of speeches from Irish history has traitor to the English crown Robert Emmet’s speech vindicating violent extremism. Track two is violent extemist Padraic Pearse’s speech over the grave of violent extremist O’ Donovan Rossa. Rummaging through there’s a compilation of songs recorded in the 70s and 80s about the H blocks which were jammed full of violent extremists and that box set of Christy Moore has all sorts of eulogies to violent extremists. Gosh even the Dubliners have a song about blowing up Nelson’s column in their home town.Sometimes that stuff even sneaks into the house without your knowledge. What could be less violently extreme than buying a three cd compilation of folk music with Lindisfarne and Gerry Rafferty? Then you discover some bugger has slipped in Dominic Behan’s version of The Patriot Game which actively condones shooting cops. Oh yeah, and there’s those NWA albums.

But Jesus that’s nothing compared to what’s on the bookshelves. Books on the IRA in the Belfast pogroms of the 1920s, another half dozen histories of the IRA plus a copy of its standing orders bought from Amazon, biographies of violent extremists De Valera, Collins, Connolly, Mellows and god knows who else plus a little book on Milltown cemetery looking at IRA graves.

That’s just the Irish stuff. Loads of books about the conquest of the Americas by  violent religious extremists from Spain. Volumes by and about  Che Guevara, Trotsky, Giap. Even the European books are full of violent extremists. At least the ones about the French Revolution are fairly free from religion but that Oliver Cromwell was one seriously violent god botherer so a lot of the books on English history are full of extremism. Blimey to make it worse yesterday I received the DVD of the film Winstanley about a violent extremist who got on the wrong side of Cromwell.

Let’s not forget the biographies of Stalin, Hitler and Mao. None of them turned their noses up at either violence or extremism.

Should I take it all down to the nearest police station and hand myself in or throw it all in the nearest skip?

Or should I just be grateful that I’m not a young Muslim who can’t get excited by New Labour?

7 responses to “Violent extremism – a searching inventory”

  1. Mark Victorystooge Avatar
    Mark Victorystooge

    Me too. I have lots of things about me that might be deemed “extremist”. When you’re too radical for “Dave’s Part”, you know your collar might soon be felt…

    “Extremist” is a more slippery and wider term than “terrorist”, and even the latter term was abused in practice.

    Like

  2. I’m prepared to take a risk and take some of the worst material off your hands. I know, I know, but that’s the sort of generous self sacrificing comrade that I am.

    Like

  3. […] thoughts on this from Liam, who is wondering whether now would be a good time to get rid of those Wolfe Tones […]

    Like

  4. Yes the analogy between Irish republicanism and Muslim radicals in Europe today is striking. Anyone who’s seen the film Gangs of New York will know that Irish Catholics were regarded as dangerous aliens just as Europe’s Muslim minority is today. Eventually Europe’s Muslims will achieve enough economic and political power to put a stop to this nonsense, just as Irish Americans did.

    I rewrote a few of the old ballads last year when the Gaza murders were taking place and fired it across the Internet: doubtless the powers that be have me on the database…

    FOR PALESTINE

    I met with Sheikh Ishmael and he took me by the hand
    And said “How is wounded Palestine and how does she stand?”
    She’s the most distressful country that ever yet was seen
    They are killing women and little children there for wearing of the green
    True, tormented by the tyrant some have turned towards the dark
    Like Samson sacrifice their frail bodies to the tribal gods of blood
    Which serves the foeman well before the window of the world
    And sanctifies the missiles from Confederate Yankistan

    Then since yet we’re branded there with Zion’s cruel blue
    Sure Palestine’s sons will ne’er forget to Liberty prove true
    You may build walls, cut down the olive grove and cast the branches on the sod
    But they will take root and flourish there though underfoot are trod
    When law can stop the blades of grass from growing as they grow
    And when the leaves in summertime their verdure dare not show
    Then we will change the colour that we wear in the shibeen But till that day, please Allah, we’ll live and die still wearing of the green

    But if at last our colour should be torn from Palestine’s heart
    Her sons with shame and sorrow from the wounded land will part
    I’ve heard tell of Outremer Europa, the land beyond the sea
    Where rich and poor stand equal in the light of freedom’s day
    Oh Palestine! Must we leave you, driven by a tyrant’s hand?
    Must we seek a mother’s blessing from a strange and distant land?
    Where the cruel star of Zion no more shall be seen
    And where our Diaspora will yet serve Palestine, still
    wearing of the green

    FOR ISRAEL

    What has made that fearful sound
    What on the threshold stands?
    It never yet crossed Negev Desert because
    Uncle Sam and the sky are friends
    But this is not the old sea
    Nor this the old sea shore
    What gave that roar of mockery
    That roar in the sea’s roar?

    The ghost of Yasmin’s children
    Is beating at the door

    The Sheikhs have gone to China
    In time the Mandarins may pay them heed
    For oil is thicker than blood methinks
    And dollars know no higher price
    Shakes that money maker
    That equal opportune arms dealer
    Ninety cents upon the dollar
    As he transfers the funds offshore

    The ghost of Yasmin’s children
    Is beating at the door

    The Zionites fight free speech on campus
    And all must pay them heed
    For histories are there to prove
    That none of like inheritance
    Suffered such a grievous wound as they
    Yet moral capital may erode in time
    Like shifting sands before the sea
    Who remembers the Armenians
    Among those that seek Palestine to slay?

    The ghost of Yasmin’s children
    Is beating at the door

    Jihadist and Crusader
    Abase themselves before
    The Bronze Age God of Battles
    The old songs sung once more
    A Heimat for Yahweh’s Herrenvolk
    A Caliphate cleansed of kaffirite doubt
    No god but the Market
    In the heart of Rational Man
    He plays both ends against the middle
    As he transfers the funds offshore

    The ghosts of Yasmin’s children
    Of Rachel’s murdered children
    Of Yasmin’s slaughtered children
    Are beating at the door

    Like

  5. Armoured cars and tanks and guns,
    came to take away our CDs,
    and all was right with the world.

    Like

  6. Yes the analogy between Irish republicanism and Muslim radicals in Europe today is striking.

    It’s worth mentioning that the solicitor who represented the Birmingham Six has also represented a number of British Muslims in recent years. Here’s an article he wrote on the comparison.

    Like

  7. Mark Victorystooge Avatar
    Mark Victorystooge

    “He” is a woman. I know, a name like Gareth gives the wrong impression, but I have met her.

    Like

Leave a comment

Trending