This article by Madeleine Bunting is from The Guardian. There’s a bizarre suggestion that a property developer can have morals but the rest is very good.

Drums, loudhailers, chanting slogans. It is a very old-fashioned kind of politics that can be heard on the high street in Kings Heath, Birmingham.image

But Salma Yaqoob, the prospective parliament candidate at the centre of the hubbub, represents a quiet revolution. “Bankers bailed out, people sold out,” she shouts into the loudhailer outside the banks. The passing cars sound their horns in support.

She is the most prominent Muslim woman in British public life. She wears a headscarf, a powerful symbol of a faith she has accommodated with her passionate leftwing politics. She is standing as a candidate for the tiny and fractured Respect party.

In some streets around the new constituency of Hall Green, her poster is on every window. Since her narrow defeat for Westminster in 2005, she has built up support through her work as a local councillor, as well as building a national profile through her appearances on BBC’s Question Time.

She might just topple Labour from a seat in an area which, in 1997, it counted as one of its safest. Boundary changes have brought much of the old Sparkbrook and Small Heath constituency (Labour majority: 19,526) into the new Hall Green.

Yaqoob is one of a small group who has a good chance of making history as one of the first British Muslim women MPs. Her result is looking close, while across Birmingham, Shabana Mahmood is fighting Clare Short’s old seat, Ladywood. In Bolton South, Yasmin Qureshi inherits a big Labour majority, and Rushanara Ali could well take the Bethnal Green seat back for Labour. Yaqoob’s headscarf at Westminster may prompt a few headlines – both here and abroad – but few will fully grasp the small revolution these women are spearheading in these communities, and how they are introducing to British electoral politics a constituency of Muslim women, many of whom don’t speak English and were in previous elections confined to the backroom, the private family areas of the house, whenever canvassers or candidates came to the doorstep.

Back on the high street in Kings Heath, the noisy protesters crowding around the diminutive figure of Yaqoob are furious. Gurt Singh has been running a steel and timber yard all his life, but he has had to put his 10 staff on a three-day week to avoid redundancies. “I reckon I have only a few months left. I can’t get credit from the bank.”

Essa Altaf is equally outraged. A property developer, he has had to lay off eight men. “I don’t want to lay off any more, I have morals. I know redundancy affects a whole family and then the whole community. Why do I have morals, and the banks don’t?”

By now I am surrounded by men who all run small businesses in the building industry all telling a bitter story of the recession. The boom in this area of Birmingham has always been fragile and the recession hit quickly and hard. Jobs are the biggest subject on the doorstep, says Yaqoob. She knows well that the issues, even at national elections, are local: jobs, schools, antisocial behaviour, police, housing. The Iraq and Afghanistan wars rarely come up, she says – the surge in anti-war sentiment, which helped her in 2005, is unlikely to feature this time round. Constituents’ economic security is far more pressing.

What will help Yaqoob is that her Labour opponent, Roger Godsiff, who has held the seat since 1992, has been badly damaged by the expenses scandal. His second-home claims were among the highest in England, and despite charging £163,885 to the taxpayer in 2007-08, last year he spoke in only five debates and voted in 56% of divisions.

Yaqoob was wooed by Labour after 2005.She acknowledges that “My values are traditional Labour, but New Labour has gone to the right”. She was even courted by the Liberal Democrats and the Tories, a tribute to her rare capacity for fair-minded plain speaking, most evident in her Question Time appearance earlier this year, at Wootton Bassett, when she earned respect for her handling of questions about British soldiers killed in Afghanistan, a war she opposes.

But she has stuck with Respect, despite its internal disputes, since 2005, and is probably now better known than her party. She is accused by prominent Labour and Liberal Democrat Muslims of “leading the community into a “cul-de-sac” but defends her politics vigorously.

“I couldn’t speak like I do if I was in Labour. I’m not here as a career politician, but because I want to offer an alternative to the neo-liberal model, which is patently failing. I now punch above my weight, working with other parties and influencing them. I want to try and open the space for discussion and debate, which is crucial right now, and nudge Labour into a more principled position.”

She says she won’t “make a tactic into a principle”, clearly indicating that she would come back to Labour on the right terms. In the meantime, her gamble to be her own woman and to speak her mind without having to submit to party discipline is surviving against all the odds. A recent independent assessment argued that she is among Birmingham’s three most influential councillors.

Ironically, her toughest battles are probably within the Muslim community. Contrary to assumptions that this is where the core of her support lies, she has had to pick her way very carefully through the sensitivities of conservatives within her community. The old Sparkbrook and Small Heath had the highest number of Muslim votes of any constituency in the country, and many of them are now in Yaqoob’s patch.

“I’ve had death threats and criticism that I support gays – because I have a clear anti-discrimination position – and there have been claims that it is haram [forbidden in Islam] to vote for women. People say to me, ‘Have you no shame?’ and they accuse me of immodesty
and ask my husband why he lets me speak in public. It’s still an uphill struggle.”

But she has been winning even her fiercest critics round. “Some people who made out fatwas against voting for a woman have now been saying that I’m the right candidate. I have been invited into mosques – some of which don’t even have facilities for women to pray – to give the Friday sermons.”

Yaqoob is well aware that she is a challenge to traditional Muslim political culture – not just because she is a woman, but because she is not afraid to speak her mind. She has openly criticised the way the postal vote has been misused in Birmingham to strengthen the traditional biraderi – clan affiliations. In practice, what this means is that a community fixer will offer a party hundreds of votes in return for favours.

She recognises that many non-Muslim voters can feel threatened by her as a Muslim. “I’m between a rock and a hard place,” she says. “I have to jump hurdles because of the way I look. Firstly, I have to make it clear that I don’t support terrorism, secondly, that I’m British, thirdly, that I don’t just lobby for Muslims and lastly, that I’m not a Trojan horse for sinister Islamist plots.

“People still question me about the hijab as a symbol of oppression. I try to stay patient and build a relationship of trust. For a real discussion, people have to be able to hear each other: someone has to pull the barriers down. People have a genuine fear, and you need to deal with it or you are dehumanising them – it won’t just go away.”

Her training as a psychotherapist clearly influences how she understands political conflict and how she is still able to deal patiently with questions faced since she first went to university more than 20 years ago. It makes her voice distinctive in public life – and it’s easy to see why she’s clocked up five appearances on Question Time, the showcase for aspiring politicians.

The key factor benefiting Yaqoob is the decline of the close bond between Muslims and Labour, which has defined the politics of the Muslim community for two generations. Disillusion with foreign policy, most notably in Iraq and Afghanistan, as well as on domestic economic issues, is likely to slash the Muslim votes in Birmingham.

While Labour’s successes in Birmingham in the past 13 years are evident in the city centre – the newly redeveloped Bullring shopping centre with its iconic architecture, for example – it’s a model of urban regeneration, which hasn’t percolated through to the neighbouring Victorian terraced streets, where shops and businesses are closing down.

A younger generation of educated Muslims no longer demonstrates the expected deference to the “village elders”, who once directed the family and delivered a bloc vote for Labour. Some are impressed by the Conservatives’ emphasis on family values, hard work and responsibility – it is a message that has appealed to successful immigrant communities in the past. This election will almost certainly see the arrival of the first Conservative Muslim MPs: men have been selected for Bromsgrove and Stratford-upon-Avon, two safe Conservative seats in the West Midlands.

Even in Ladywood, the Conservatives smell the possibility of giving Labour a run for their money. David Cameron made an appearance in the constituency last weekend. The Conservative candidate, Nusrat Ghani, also a Muslim, and Mahmood both grew up in this area of Birmingham. Both can call on the family connections vital to winning votes. Mahmood’s father is the chair of the Birmingham Labour party.

Both are able to get beyond the “front room campaigning” of previous elections; candidates and canvassers sit in family sitting rooms and are served delicious tea spiced with green cardamom, while the conversations run on in Urdu or Mirpuri. The questions here are about family and which village the candidate is “from” back in Pakistan. There is no mistaking the pride and delight among these women to see a female candidate.

“My generation had a much more traditional life and you listened to your husband on who to vote for, but my daughters have a completely different outlook,” says Maqsood Bibi through a translator. “It’s a good thing for women to come forward so that it is not just men in politics. As a Muslim, I believe God gives you, as a woman, the same rights as he gives to the men. So why shouldn’t you become an MP?”

Along the street, Gulshan Begum was even more forthright. “My generation of women are often illiterate and we need women in power to support us.”

Their generation has waited a long time for the moment when this may finally come true.

15 responses to “Respect candidate spearheads quiet revolution to get Muslim women involved in politics”

  1. Without doubt there will be some muslem woman sneaking down to the ballot box.Good to see Salma gettin the gloves off.

    Like

  2. This article by Madeleine Bunting is … very good
    As a puff piece for Salma, as analysis it’s dire.One example:
    she has been winning even her fiercest critics round
    This isn’t in quotes, isn’t given as Salma’s opinion. Where are the quotes from ” her fiercest critics” to indicate this opinion has any veracity?
    Ms.Bunting has form when it comes to failing to think that propositions about the world need to be grounded in fact:
    belief is a commitment not a proposition; faith, as in “I have faith in you”, is an expression of confidence, not an assertion of the existence of something
    Perhaps she should be asked to join Respect, where such baseless faith appears to be the norm.

    Like

  3. What a sad sectarian world you occupy. You should pop along to Jim Denham’s site. You are more likely to find fellow travelers there.

    Like

  4. Ger

    For once you are far too generous. The campaign in Hall Green is truly inspirational, Salma is making a huge impact, she has a serious chance of winning, this would be a historic breakthrough.

    Yet there remain those who cannot, refuse, to recognise this. They elevate tactical differences to the point of a principle that means with 10 days to go they would prefer to campaign for no-hope candidatures rather than help out in Hall Green where rather than having an outside chance of saving a deposit, Salma is fighting to win.

    Mark P

    Like

  5. It would require a very special type of myopia not to appreciate that Salma’s election to Westminster would be a really important victory for the left. The good thing is that it seems pretty likely.

    From Belgium comes this report (in French) of a meeting organised by the LCR on the theme of Islamophobia.

    http://www.lcr-lagauche.be/cm/index.php?view=article&id=1633:conferences-debats-sur-lislamophobie-avec-ilham-moussaid-photos-et-videos&option=com_content&Itemid=53

    Like

  6. Ger Francis – thank-you for those kind words.

    Liam – or a difference of opinion about the nature of Respect, and whether its advance helps or hinders building a left not dominated by other class forces. We can see from Mark P’s contribution the argument that will be made as long as Respect continues in its present form – we have a block of votes from the Muslim community, so Respect’s needs should always take priority over the left’s, because it has a greater chance of winning elections (where it has any presence). A strategy for emaculating the left as an adjunct to Respect.
    Perhaps it is likely, but we’re never going to get an accurate assessment of that from those inwith the organisation, who seem capable of only hearing good things about themselves and not capable of believing that anyone could honestly holding a view different from theirs. Much as you seem to claim about the SWP, but in your contibution and that of Mr.Francis no acknowledgement is made that the Bunting article really does just swallow uncritically the Yaqoob campaign perspective; fair enough you agree with it, but not to accept that it is a partisan viewpoint and that others don’t share your triumphalism, let alone your political stance, divorces you from reality.

    Like

  7. The article does also point out she’ll be happy to go to the Labour Party at some point;

    “She says she won’t “make a tactic into a principle”, clearly indicating that she would come back to Labour on the right terms.”

    It does make you wonder what the future for Respect is as an organisation when their most likely electoral prospect is prepared to contemplate dumping the organisation.
    Where would she be as a Labour MP? Probably somewhat to the right of John Cruddas I’d say.

    Like

  8. Richard Searle Avatar
    Richard Searle

    That’s alright then Bill,
    you then be able to vote for her
    Tis’ not PR’s position to call for a Vote for Labour

    Like

  9. This is worse than pathetic. Neither of these two so-called critics are campaigning for an outside left candidate with a hope in hell of saving their deposit let alone winning. Yet they presume to preach on what basis precisely? Salma has put generations of mainly white, male leftists to shame with the challenge she is posing in Hall Green. The breakthrough she is on the verge of making will be historic, made mainly without the assistance of the major organisations organised far left. The fact that she has done this without their ‘help’ tells us more about the uselessness of these organisations than her. Quite why the RMT and FBU want to throw their money away backing their joke candidatures is entirely beyond me.

    Meamwhile on Saturday I understand the local SWP branch were holding a street stall, selling papers. How quaint and symbolic of their utter irrelevance.

    Mark P

    Like

  10. I don’t live in Birmingham so I don’t have to make that choice.
    And I’ve been around long enough to have seen hundreds of *historic* breakthroughs.
    And yes like the rest of the left – including so I gather Respect – in most places people will probably have no choice but to vote Labour.
    *Shock*

    Like

  11. ‘we have a block of votes from the Muslim community, so Respect’s needs should always take priority over the left’s, because it has a greater chance of winning elections (where it has any presence). A strategy for emaculating the left as an adjunct to Respect.’

    WTF are you going on about??? Incoherent ramblings. And that’s being charitable. Try again. On second thoughts, maybe best not to bother.

    As for the Guardian falling for campaign propaganda, more rubbish. The dogs in the street know Salma has a very good chance of winning.

    Like

  12. Ger Francis – I’m sorry that your English isn’t up to understanding my comments. Mark P’s last comment gives a pretty good guide to what I’m saying. Respect appeals to Muslims as Muslims not as workers, and uses the head start that gives it over the left to say “we have a chance of winning, so you have to support what we’re doing rather than trying to build an independent left bloc”.

    As for the Guardian falling for campaign propaganda, more rubbish
    They’re demonstrably printing campaign propaganda, and you are being extremely dishonest in denying it, but then abuse of those who disagree with you does seem to be much more your style than any actual engagement with points raised. I’ve pointed out how the Bunting article simply reproduces what your campaign wants to say. If you simply dismiss this as rubbish, not only are you unconvincing, but you cast doubt on everything you and your candidate have to say, as any independent observer might assume that they would be drawn from the same well of self-delusion.

    Like

  13. Thats right Madeliene Bunting is so incapable of coming to the conclusion that Salma Yaqoob is not only an outstanding candidate but in with a a real chance of wnning without being ‘duped’? Where did you find that line of argument, Trotskyism for Dummies?

    Meanwhile you treat us to the fantasy land of an ‘independent left bloc’ which after thirteen years will be lucky to save a single deposit, goodness only knows why the RMT and FBU are even giving this bunch of jokers the time of day, never mind their members’ money.

    And all you can do is sneer. Come back and have something useful to say when your make-believe independent left bloc resembles anything like the support Salma has won. Oh I forget, the core of her support are Muslims so do doesn’t count. Now what does that line of argument smack of… pathetic. She’s so much better off without you and your like.

    Mark P

    Like

  14. maybe best guys to just agree to disagree . . .

    Like

  15. ‘Respect appeals to Muslims as Muslims not as workers’

    Crass 1980’s Militant style insenstivity to the realities of racism, its impact in shaping identities and understanding of race and class.

    I am proud to say that one of our achievements has been to further marginalise on the left this kind of failed, crap politics.

    Like

Leave a reply to Mark P Cancel reply

Trending