imageSome windows were broken at Tory party head office during today’s protest but, as Lindsey German argues in this article on Counterfire’s site, the real violence is being inflicted on the poorest and most vulnerable by the ConDem government.

(I do think Lindsey could have been a bit harder on the thoroughly unimpressive Aaron Porter. There’s a young man looking to follow the Phil Woolas route of student “leader”, union functionary, Labour MP if ever you saw one. There are lots of photos here and Junius has another good report here.)

What a brilliant student demo today. Tens of thousands from every sector of education – a pretty good group of school students, as well as FE and Uni. They were political, aware, militant, totally fed up with the government. They came in large numbers from universities not normally associated with protest: Bath, Southampton, Reading, Brunel. They signify a new mass movement formed by a generation which is facing attacks on education, welfare, pensions, housing and jobs. What kind of a future is the government offering these young people?

I received what I regard as an extremely good education and it never cost me a penny. In fact I was paid to study and came out of college without any debt. Imagine that now. Yet why should students pay for tertiary education when they don’t have to pay for primary or secondary education? All that it does is say that education is for the rich. Those discriminated against will be from working class and ethnic minority families, where the money won’t be there, especially when EMA is abolished.

Like most people I knew, I was the first of my family to go to university. Back then, quite a lot of people used to question whether it was worth educating women …because they would get married! I cannot imagine my family thinking university would be a good idea if they thought i would have had thousands of pounds worth of debt at the other end …let alone the tens of thousands debt students now face.

I was reflecting on this after hearing NUS president Aaron Porter’s condemnation of the occupation of Tory head office as ‘disgusting’. I’m not surprised that students are angry, or that they occupy, or that a few windows are broken. What is this in comparison with the violence which this government is inflicting on the poorest and most vulnerable, who will face cuts in benefits, enforced moving out of their homes because of benefit cuts, and forced to work if they are unemployed? They are condemning working class students to a worse education than previous generations. Shouldn’t Porter be reserving the epithet of disgusting for the people who really deserve it?

Above all, his duty to his members today was to challenge a government which is attacking his members. Nick Clegg signed a pledge against tuition fees and is now implementing them. Surely he, Osborne and Cameron – all recipients of the best education money can buy – should be the focus of his wrath.

16 responses to “What a brilliant student demo today!”

  1. Absolutely. The students were right to occupy Tory HQ and we should defend their bravery and determination and say back to the campuses: organise, occupy, walk out, connect with the wider anti cuts struggle.

    We should be for gneral co-ordinated strike action in defiance of the anti union laws and completely in defence of the students against the media lies.

    Like

  2. Its taken a generation for student anger to build up. and now its finally blown its top.

    About time to.

    (For an eyewitness (by me) comment, and some nice pics, visit my blog)

    Like

  3. A lot of people involved are clearly identifiable in photos. Who knows if they will be prosecuted, but if the university administrations start acting against individuals, I predict a lot of university occupations around the country – and the NUS forced to back them or become irrelevant.

    Like

  4. Gosh! I was right.

    Simon Hughes said to Porter on Newsnight “your friend, the Labour leader” with a knowing twinkle in his eye.

    If there is one thing worst than an old scumbag careerist it’s a young scumbag careerist.

    Like

  5. […] Aufrufes ist die Webseite der National Campaign Against Fees and Cuts (NCACF), mehr bei Liam, der AWL und Ian […]

    Like

  6. Perhaps Lindsey’s reticence can be explained by the friendly way Clare Solomon debated with Mr.Porter on Newsnight, disagreeing with him on the violence, but saying she expected him to hold to his promise to vigorously oppose the “reforms”. They think more can be got from him.

    Like

  7. […] who was at the same Uni as Coatesy, has useful comments – here.  More Veteran musings here. Well-judged comments about the famous window-smashing […]

    Like

  8. Great demo and all the better for its militancy and its unexpected size. A big plus was that the students didn’t get smashed like their counterparts in Ireland. Perhaps British police trying to send message to Coalition about their own funding.

    The Tories destroyed the remains of British industry and manufacturing in the 1980s because they were no longer profitable and Thatcher’s dream was to transform Britain into the European Taiwan, an offshore island of non-union cheap labour making junk for the continent. That was always a ludicrous fantasy on the part of the ruling classes’ political puppets but quite by accident and by shear luck over time a new economy did emerge based on knowledge. The collapse of the Soviet Union gave Western capitalism a new but very temporary lease of life which allowed it to relax its neo-liberal death grip for a short period. But now, the knowledge economy is being scrapped by the Coalition as a drain on the profits of monopoly capital and an obstacle to restoring bankers bonuses but there is no prospect of this economy being replaced by anything. The Tory death grip is applied once again with full vigour or with all the vigour that a dieing and decrepid system can muster. This time the grip can only be released by a determined working class, youth and student struggle for socialism. There will be no frenzied speculators boom based on the super profits generated in the colonial world and gambling on the property market upon which some New Labour svengali can spin us a yarn about social mobility this time around. The class struggle is back on thanks to the Coalition and this time its going all the way.

    Like

  9. junius classic,its taken students a generation to wake up.Are the students reborn or what,are they some form of rear guard awakened by the morgage that their mummy and daddy cant now afford,after sweating who to vote for.

    Sorry sir, for giving you grief.The only lasting remebrance of social change in our time, has come from, the sweated class the workers.To be sold off by student Marks/Engels lunch time rallies.

    Like

  10. I gather that on Radio London this morning Clare Solomon said that she “did not condone violence.”
    Funny how these incidents show people’s real metal isn’t it?

    Like

  11. clare solomon ULU and Counter fire “does not condone violence” http://www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode/p00bz7hf/Vanessa_Feltz_11_11_2010/

    see 57 minutes 20 seconds

    Like

  12. They certainly got themselves noticed!
    The demo was covered extensively, not only by the BBC News, but also on ABC and RT.

    What’s annoying me is the idea that it was somehow “unexpected”, or “spontaneous”.
    The NUS and UCU have been organising this for months.
    They’ve had a joint web site up since early September at http://www.demo2010.org/
    They extensively publicised the event and provided coaches to bus in thousands of their members into London.

    Given that students face a 3-fold fee increase in fees, which will leave them in debt for years after graduation, it was predictable that large numbers of students would show up.

    Many will opt out of Higher Education altogether.
    This is a trend that’s been occurring ever since Tuition Fees were introduced.

    In the past 8 years, the UK went from having the third highest graduation rate amongst industrialised countries, to 15th place
    HE lecturers also face cuts in course-funding and the threat of redundancy.

    Aaron Porter of the NUS and Sally Hunt of UCU, predictably condemned “the minority” who broke into the Tory HQ. I tend to see this as the spontaneity of youth myself.

    More important, now that everyone’s gone home, how many of the 50,000 present are any clearer about where to go from here?

    One big weakness of all the anti-cuts protests so far has been their lack of coordination:
    The TUC lobby, the FBU and RMT strike actions, the RMT-led march & rally with Inner London NUT, FBU, PCS, the SERTUC meeting, the numerous local rallies.

    The Government will ignore the protests whatever happens. The only way that the Cuts can be stopped is by bringing down the Coalition. The Liberals are its weakest link. Pressure needs to be brought to bear on their MP’s.

    Spontaneity isn’t enough.
    We need:-

    * A one day general strike will break down the union sectionalism and a big step in rebuilding the confidence of union members.

    * A National demonstration in London could attract at least 250,000.

    Steps need to be taken now to organise for this and then build beyond it.
    We also need to be raising governmental slogans to answer the question of what happens when the Coalition falls.

    Like

  13. Prianikoff, spot on. The demo was tremdndous- it will energise struggles to come. Tonight Manchester students occupied temporarily-

    http://manunioccupation.blogspot.com/

    we need to make it bigger and better.

    Let’s run with the enthusiasm but also work out tactics and a strategy.

    Support every action in campuses and workplaces to build towards generalised strike action and anti union laws, show we’re ready to fight back, drop charges against all anti-capitalist and anti cuts protestors

    Let’s continue to pass motions for a general strike and generalised strike action in defiance of anti-union laws

    Build for national student demo in London and solidairty with the students- drop the charges, for uncondiitonal support for the necessary self-defence and concerted action to occupy and resist the police- whay the media call ‘violence’

    For occupations up and down the country

    For messages of support to and votes for strike action

    Like

  14. I’m not sure why there is more debate on the George Galloway than this- surely this is more significant for the working class than the secional interests of a small left(ish) group?

    This should be a time for the left to unite in a common struggle, to drop the charges, against all cuts, to push for co-ordinated strike action and mass demonstrations to drop all the charges, for more occupations and direct action.

    e.g.http://anticuts.com/2010/11/12/press-release-24th-november-walkout-and-day-of-action/

    Like

  15. One thing not to DO is Follow the Leader. We are always GIVEN our Leaders. Not always as obvious as that soon-to-be MP, Aaron Porter.

    Like

Leave a reply to Jodley Cancel reply

Trending