A couple of months ago it would have seemed improbable that a former drag queen turned daytime TV presenter would become the voice of the outraged opposition to the Con Dems for millions of people. Take a bow Paul O’Grady.

It was even more unlikely that a group of students would trash the Tory headquarters. Clearly things are moving in British society and every political organisation is going to have to make hard choices. No. That’s wrong. They are easy choices. Do you stand with or against people moving into action against the Con Dems?

The Green Party’s Jenny Jones who is also a member of the Metropolitan Police Authority failed the test on the very first question. While it’s obviously daft to drop a fire extinguisher onto a moving crowd of friends and cops Paul O’Grady got it right by explaining that it should have been used to batter open the doors of Tory offices. Jenny Jones, who self identifies as being on the progressive wing of politics,  on the other hand opted to issue a scabbing statement saying:

"In my 40 year experience of going to protests, the violent people aren’t real protestors at all. They are criminals who use the cover of a demo to do as much damage as they can. Real protestors want to make their point and get good headlines for their cause.”

That’s exactly the sort of quote that a class traitor would offer to the Daily Mail. (Note to self – write something about Aaron Porter.)

The party’s honour is saved by the Young Greens who rightly say:

“This is what you get when you condemn a whole generation to a lifetime of debt, unaffordable housing and a lack of decent jobs.”

They add:

“We fully support direct action, occupations and other activities that utilise sensible tactics to show the Government we will not accept higher fees, and we will not accept cuts to higher education funding.”

Just occasionally you end up obliged to support daft tactics as well but let’s not quibble. The point is that a fault line is going to start running through every trade union, students’ union, political party, Christmas party and football team as the struggle heats up. It’ll be around trivial stuff like vandalism but underneath it will be a choice about whether you’re on the side of the fighters or the capitulators. Jenny Jones won’t be the last to jump the wrong way. That’s exactly the sort of “leadership” that needs to be swept away by a new radical movement.

13 responses to “Wheat and chaff”

  1. “Real protestors want to make their point and get good headlines for their cause”

    There speak someone who has clearly never been near a demonstration in her life, except perhaps for the odd staged photo op for the local papers.

    Like

  2. 100% the right position we are all in right now. The slightly barbed support people at work have advanced since I went to the march and none of them did reminds me of this every day. ‘oh, I couldn’t ask you about that because you were on the march’. Fuck em. I know what side I’m on.

    Like

  3. Heard this song on Radio 4 of all places the other day and it immediately made me think of the student demo for some reason. Such an uplifting song:

    THE JARROW SONG
    (Composer : Alan Price)
    Alan Price

    My name is Geordie McIntyre, An’ the Bairns don’t even have a fire
    So the wife says “Geordie, go to London Town!”
    And if they don’t give us half a chance , Don’t even give us a second glance
    Then Geordie, with my blessings, burn them down

    Come on follow the Geordie boys, They’ll fill your heart with joy
    They’re marching for their freedom now
    Come on follow the Jarrow lads, They’ll make your heart feel glad
    They’re singing now, yes now is the hour

    My name is little Billy White, And I know what’s wrong and I know what’s right
    An’ the wife says “Geordie, go to London Town!”
    An’ if they don’t give us a couple of bob, Won’t even give you a decent job
    Then Geordie, with my blessings, burn them down

    Come on follow the Geordie boys, They’ll fill your heart with joy
    They’re marching for their freedom now
    Come on follow the Jarrow lads, The joy’ll make your heart feel glad
    They’re singing now, yes now is the hour

    [snip]

    My name is little Alan Price, I tried to be nice all of my life
    But I’m afraid that up to date it doesn’t work
    Because when you lay some money down, The people try to put you down
    Now where do I stand, either side or not

    Come on follow this Geordie boy, He’ll try and fill your heart with joy
    We’re marching for our freedom now
    Come on follow this Jarrow lad, He’ll try and make your heart feel glad
    We’re sayin’ it now, yes now is the hour.

    Like

  4. history repeats itself, “non-violent” in the German Greens’ program of 1980 meant acceptance of state violence including 1999 bombing of Yugoslavia and 2001 bombing of Afghanistan when they were in government … welcome in Europe! ;-(

    Like

  5. Liam: you are a bit of a player on the old music scene. Remember that campaign last year to prevent the X Factor song from getting to number one, I can’t remember the song that was chosen to oppose it but I reckon if you got a facebook campaign to get the Jarrow Song to this year’s Xmas number one it might have some legs. How about getting it to go viral.

    Like

  6. Paul O’Grady is closer to us than Jenny Jones on this, thanks for posting.

    Like

  7. And yet, and yet…
    Jenny Jones statement appears on the Green Party national website not the statement from their youth wing which is curiously absent (one would think that they would carry the statement from their own students!)
    Today another statement appears on students from the deputy leader which is completely bland.
    While for decent people like Derek Wall I am sure it would have been automatic, Caroline Lucas MP appears to have shown no support for the Millbank protestors….

    Like

  8. Well noted Derek but are you and the Green Left going to move a motion of censure on Jenny Jones in the national and London organisations?

    Surely the result will be of interest to all of us.

    Like

  9. “Well noted Derek but are you and the Green Left going to move a motion of censure on Jenny Jones in the national and London organisations?”
    I often wonder why Trots are so keen on using bureaucratic tactics and stirring up civil war in other organisations and so damning of ‘stalinists’ who use those tactics against them.
    The issue surely is to argue for strong policy supporting the students rather than attacking individuals.

    Like

  10. Not big on holding your public representatives to account are you, Pete?

    Like

  11. Mark P, absolutely- but exactly what policy has Jenny gone against?
    I disagree with what Jenny said but that doesn’t mean I think that the way to deal with it is to start bashing people. A stronger message would be to stand with the Green students and get their stance taken up by the entire Green Party. The you have means to distance yourself from an elected member who goes against policy.

    In my organisation we have a whole series of accountability structures to deal work with our elected members- but then with nearly 10,000 of them at an Assembly, Senate, Regional, Departmental, and local level we need it, and it still doesn’t work!

    Like

  12. Then you have means … even

    Like

  13. […] more disappointing was the failure of a leading Green to get it: The Green Party’s Jenny Jones who is also a member of the Metropolitan Police Authority … […]

    Like

Leave a comment

Trending